Newsom’s death row commutations reopen California’s death penalty fight
Gov. Gavin Newsom moved to commute more than 500 death sentences, drawing fierce objections from victims’ families and a legal fight over what life without parole means.
Steve Herr attended 203 court dates before Daniel Wozniak was convicted and sentenced to death for killing Herr’s son, Samuel Eliezer Herr, and Juri Kibuishi in Orange County in 2010. He thought the sentencing ended a long nightmare. Newsom’s commutation move brought it back.
California Gov. Gavin Newsom has moved to commute the death sentences of more than 500 people on the state’s death row. NBC News reported that 548 condemned inmates are affected, though Newsom needs the California Supreme Court’s consent for 382 of them to be moved off death row and resentenced to life without the possibility of parole.
Why it matters: The action is one of the most consequential moves against capital punishment in recent history, according to NBC News. It does not simply erase the cases or free the people convicted in them. But it would replace death sentences with life without parole for hundreds of inmates, a major practical step away from the death penalty in a state that still has it on the books.
For victims’ relatives, that distinction does not make the decision feel smaller. Faye Jenkins, whose daughter and son-in-law were tortured and killed in their Riverside County home in 2008, said Newsom had overridden voters. “We voted for this,” she said outside the Orange County District Attorney’s Office in Santa Ana.
The political fault line: California voters considered the issue in 2016 and rejected a measure to abolish the death penalty by a relatively narrow margin. Newsom’s action has therefore revived a dispute that is legal, moral and democratic all at once: whether an elected governor should use executive power to move the state away from a punishment voters chose to retain.
The catch: Orange County District Attorney Todd Spitzer argued that people sentenced to life without parole can still leave prison through legal mechanisms. Loyola Marymount University law professor Stan Goldman agreed that mechanisms exist, but said mass releases or even individual releases were, in practical terms, very unlikely. The phrase “without parole” is less simple in law than it is in ordinary speech, which is not a comforting detail for families already asked to relive the cases.
The immediate question is whether the California Supreme Court will approve the transfers for the 382 inmates whose sentences require its consent.
The world's most important stories. Explained clearly. Delivered daily.
- Every morning
- Five-minute read
- Unsubscribe anytime